View Single Post
Old 12-16-2017, 06:26 PM   #1
Steady Hand
Senior Member
Join Date: May 2015
Location: Germany
Posts: 148
Unhappy From Mync to EDIUS bin (with little success)

Hi! I'm (as many others) trying to understand the Mync philosophy. In my primitive understanding Mync adds as a stand-alone program what EDIUS' bin lacks.
So I started to import my material into Mync, added some metadata, organized it in catalogs, but what next?
I tried these steps to make EDIUS know about the Mync stuff:
  • Export a catalog as FCP XML and import that as project in EDIUS 8. There was some odd error message, but still most or all clips seems to be imported. It seems all material has to have the same frame rate (which was not true for my catalog). Unfortunately Mync export does not create a warning, and EDIUS import only logs the errors in a CVS file located in the same directory as the XML file.
  • Create a storyboard and import that into EDIUS. Here the storyboard seems to "convert" the clips to a common frame rate. Unfortunately why importing the storyboard, I get a new sequence, but no clips in the bin. Marking all clips in the sequence and selecting "add to bin" seems to separate video and audio: If I add he clip from the bin to the timeline again, there is no audio track. Also I don't see where the metadata from Mync went to...

Despite of these problems I miss some essential functions in Mync:
  • Unified naming: Different sources use different naming conventions for clips. Some are named sequentially with or without a prefix, some include the date and time (in a variety of formats), etc. To help chronological ordering, a suitable common file/clip naming would be useful. However there is no mechanism for batch/mass renaming of clips using some user-definable rules. Outside Mync and EDIUS I can rename images and clips using exiftool with commands like these (Windows batch file):
    exiftool "-FileName<${CreateDate}_${model;}_%%f.%%e" -d %%Y%%m%%d_%%H%%M -ext jpg %1
    exiftool "-FileName<${TrackCreateDate}_%%f.%%e" -d %%Y%%m%%d_%%H%%M -ext mp4 %1
  • Smarter smart catalogs: You cannot select still images via keywords in their metadata (just for example), and you cannot export a smart catalog like an ordinary catalog.
There are many more issues, of course, but those are enough for this thread I think.
Steady Hand is offline   Reply With Quote