Primary Color Correction in Edius 9 bug.

[nictau]

I am quite sure, that I am not the only one who has recognized the anomaly in the Primary Color Correction tool.
If you drag the RGB sliders individually in one direction, the other RGB sliders will also move. It is very annoying. Everything works fine in Edius 8.
Is the release date of the next update already known? I need this function for a current project.

[antonsvideo]

this is normal, it is the same in EDIUS8

if you say reduce red, it will alter the green and blue, there is no other way

[nictau]

this is normal, it is the same in EDIUS8

if you say reduce red, it will alter the green and blue, there is no other way

Anton, try to move JUST the red, blue or green in E8. The other RGB sliders stay where they are. Not so in E9.

See the comparison pics taken from E8 and E9.

[nictau]

See the comparison pics taken from E8 and E9.
In both programs I have just moved the blue slider.

[kpot]

See the comparison pics taken from E8 and E9.
In both programs I have just moved the blue slider.

Thats interesting. I didnt realize that difference between 8 and 9.
But I think I should like the 8-Method?
Why not ???
Any Ideas?
Thanks kurt

[tingsern]

I don't drag the sliders - it is too inaccurate. I create a LUT outside of EDIUS and load that using PCC ... works much better.

[antonsvideo]

See the comparison pics taken from E8 and E9.
In both programs I have just moved the blue slider.

from your screenshots, it looks like you want to change color temp, why not drag the color temp slider

it appears EDIUS8 had a bug then because if I reduce blue, it will alter the remaining values

or maybe it is the other way and 9 has a bug

[nictau]

or maybe it is the other way and 9 has a bug

The way E8 is handling it makes much more sense and is more precise.

Grass Valley - any opinion?

[franceschilla5]

it is a bug because the variation if done several times by raising to the maximum a value of a color the other two colors will have almost always different values

[nictau]

it is a bug because the variation if done several times by raising to the maximum a value of a color the other two colors will have almost always different values

Confirmed.

[kpot]

I don't drag the sliders - it is too inaccurate. I create a LUT outside of EDIUS and load that using PCC ... works much better.

Which software are you using for creating LUTs outsside of Edius?
Thanks - kurt

[tingsern]

Which software are you using for creating LUTs outsside of Edius?
Thanks - kurt

3DLUT

https://3dlutcreator.com/

[kpot]

Hi:

Version-9: When using the Curve-Sliders (see screenshot) then it works (as I would wish that it works).
regards kurt

[nictau]

Hi:

Version-9: When using the Curve-Sliders (see screenshot) then it works (as I would wish that it works).
regards kurt

It is not about the Curve but RGB sliders.

[kpot]

It is not about the Curve but RGB sliders.

1) Yes, I know.
I was just surprised that there are different behaviors here:
Since it works with the curve sliders as in version 8, it should also work with the RGB sliders above in the same matter.
Both sliders (RGB sliders and curve sliders) should have the same behaviour.

2) Another thought:
The RGB sliders at the top are linked to the right color circle (and vice versa).
The Curve sliders are linked to the YRGB curve (and vice versa).

Could it be that GV wanted the different slider behavior that way ?

kurt